Risk assessment tool could help reduce hospital admissions for gastrointestinal bleeding

New research suggests the Oakland Score can support emergency physicians in identifying patients who can safely recover at home

Dr. Michael Sey
Dr. Michael Sey led a study involving 344 patients at eight Canadian hospitals. The findings could help support physician decision-making by identifying patients at low risk of complications from lower gastrointestinal bleeding. (London Health Sciences Centre Research Institute)

By Jillian Driessen, London Health Sciences Centre Research Institute

When a patient arrives in the emergency department with lower gastrointestinal bleeding, physicians must determine whether they can safely recover at home or need to be admitted to hospital. 

A new study led by researchers at Western University and London Health Sciences Centre Research Institute (LHSCRI) suggests a risk assessment tool called the Oakland Score could help physicians make that decision with greater confidence, potentially reducing unnecessary hospital admissions.

Lower gastrointestinal bleeding is a common reason for emergency department visits. While most patients recover without intervention, a small percentage experience serious complications that can require procedures, hospitalization or, in some cases, become life-threatening.

“The challenge is identifying the small group of patients who may develop serious complications while avoiding unnecessary admissions for those who are likely to recover safely,” said Dr. Michael Sey, an associate professor of medicine and epidemiology and biostatistics at Western's Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry and a gastroenterologist and scientist at LHSCRI. “Our study shows that the Oakland Score can help support that decision by identifying patients at low risk of complications.”

In a study involving 344 patients across eight Canadian hospitals, the Oakland Score outperformed other commonly used bleeding risk tools and performed comparably to physician clinical judgment when identifying patients who could be safely discharged. It also resulted in the fewest instances where a patient who required further observation was instead discharged home.

Dr. Michael Sey

Dr. Michael Sey says the Oakland Score could help emergency physicians identify patients at low risk of complications, potentially reducing unnecessary hospital admissions. 


The study also addressed a longstanding gap in previous research. Although the Oakland Score was designed to help identify patients who can safely go home, most previous studies examined only patients who were admitted to hospital because they were easier to follow and study. As a result, researchers and clinicians knew a great deal about how risk scores performed in these patients, but little about how they performed in patients who were discharged from emergency departments.

“We developed and validated tools to identify patients who could be discharged safely, but most of the data came from hospital admissions,” said Sey. “To truly know whether a score works, we have to study the patients who went home without an admission to hospital, the very patients the risk scores seek to identify.”

Researchers followed patients who presented to the emergency department with lower gastrointestinal bleeding between 2019 and 2024. The team tracked outcomes in both admitted and discharged patients, which allowed them to evaluate how well the Oakland Score performed in real-world emergency department settings.

Researchers compared the Oakland Score with several established bleeding risk assessment tools and physician clinical judgment. They then assessed whether patients experienced adverse outcomes, such as readmission, the need for further medical intervention, or death.

"Because we need to consider issues beyond the bleeding event, such as social supports, co-existing medical conditions, and the availability of timely follow up, there is no single risk score that can replace clinical judgment,” said Sey. “But when used alongside clinical assessment, tools like the Oakland Score can give physicians greater confidence in their decisions and help ensure patients get the right level of care.”